Cryptic Films

Wild at Heart?

None of those.
The film’s story is loosely based on H.P.Lovecraft’s stories and the title is similar to one of them.

From beyond??

Re-animator?

Neither of those.
The clue should have been…

From where I first heard My Girl.

Within the Woods

No.
What might My Girl be?

Call Girl of Cthulhu

Does that even exist?
The film stars a New Zealand wine grower.

The Hit List?

The unnamable

Who recorded My Girl?

The Last Temptation of Christ

The Temptations?

I was thinking of this My girl:

Take it or leave it?

Is that a clue Amac?

No Arena, it’s intended as a punt at an answer to Devo’s clue.

I’ve googled lots and still don’t get it.

Final extra clues…
The director is John Carpenter
The main actor, Sam Neill.