When I was young, my parents had an ice cream maker which was a bucket in a bigger wooden bucket that had a motor attached. The ice cream mixture was put in the middle with ice and salt in the outer bucket. It looked sort of like this.
They didn’t use it too much, but when they did, the flavors they made were strawberry, mint chip and caramel pecan.
The ‘Brown Bread’ one was the ‘in thing’ in the 1970/1980s - often found in restaurants usually served with fresh straweberries. The Rhubarb/Redcurrant one was my own invention.
Brown Bread ice cream sounds a bit…umm, dislikeable, but I haven’t tried it - its probably very nice My favourite flavour is salted caramel, but I’m happy to try any flavour…and no I have never made my own ice cream.
I had a go at making Cornish Vanilla ice cream once, a long time ago.
The recipe used clotted cream and egg yolks, vanilla pods and I can’t remember the rest.
This was in the days before you could buy modern electric ice cream making machines for home use, so I had to keep taking it out of the freezer compartment to try to beat while it was freezing.
It was a failure - the flavour was good but the texture was awful - it froze so hard and dense, it had to be cut into chunks, not scooped out!
I’ve never bothered making ice cream since.
Pretty much this is how my parents’ ice cream turned out. It didn’t have enough fat in it, so it turned icy. It tasted good, but it was more icy than creamy.
I used to make lots of ice cream when l had more hens, so always had lots of eggs.
I have only ever made Vanilla ice cream.
I did buy one of those ice cream makers that you stirred the ingredients, put in the freezer then stirred again. The ice cream wasn’t great.
Then l saw an advert in a local newspaper for an ICTC Gelato Chef ice cream maker and l bought it for £30. It’s an old model and quite large in size but similar new models are in their hundreds.
It has an in built freezer which saves the faff of putting the ice cream in the freezer and stirring it.
The ice cream made in the Gelato Chef is ready in 15-20 minutes. It is delicious, a bit like Mr Whippy ice cream.
This reminds me that I have an ice cream maker attachment for my stand mixer that I bought years ago that I have never used. It’s a bowl that you put in the freezer that has frozen liquid on the sides. You put the ingredients in the bowl and mix the ingredients with a special blade for the stand mixer. I wonder if it works.
It sounds similar to what you’re describing here. My guess would be that the ice cream wouldn’t be great either.
I remember ages ago a story about how EU regs had decreed certain necessary criteria as to what could and couldn’t be put into commercially made ice cream and how the big players had to abide by it. Think that some companies struggled to come to terms with how the necessary change to their historic tried and trusted recipes altered their product. Would be interesting to taste the difference between an ice cream made by Walls in say 1970 compared to one nowadays and also compare ingredients.
Edit - thinking back it was more the small independents/artisans who struggled with the required changes.
Thanks @butterscotch for that research. Interesting. Thought the Christopher Booker article I’d read in the Sunday Telegraph predated that by a few years, but it’s long ago to all be of a haze lol.
Fortunately in Australia we have a very strong farm lobby. It cannot be called ice cream if it isn’t made of cream it has to be called iced confection or some such name. That is not to say it doesn’t have other dodgy ingredients
Coles own brand ice cream which is the cheapest you can buy: