Good book, bad film

I do a quizz on a USA site often and one answer today was Slumdog millionaire. What a cra3 film-totally missed the depth of the book.

I also disliked the adaptation of the Shining-more rubbish that did not reflect Stephen King.

Having said that I thought the adaptation of The Body(again Stephen King) into the movie Stand by me was brilliant.

1 Like

Iā€™m a Stephen King fan.
Recently I bought 2 DVDā€™s - ā€˜The Shiningā€™ and ā€˜The Fire catcherā€™ I didnā€™t rate either of them.
Think Iā€™ll stick to the books in futureā€¦

Thought the Hitchikers Guide to the Galaxy was pretty poor as a film though the TV series was OK.

pretty poor? it was rubbish.

I didn`t like it either but then who cares about me? Marvin

Very few screen adaptations of Stephen Kingā€™s books seem to work. I thought ā€œNeedful Thingsā€ was good on screen and I did like the TV adaptation of The Stand. I agree that ā€œStand By Meā€ was a brilliant adaptation. I also liked ā€œDreamcatcherā€ but wasnā€™t keen on the dumbed down ā€œalienā€ ending.

Going back to Slumdog, I never read the book but totally enjoyed the film.

Never been a SK fan so canā€™t comment on his books or films.

Slum dog is a bit like watching Black Beauty-it is hinted at in films but the books show a darker side

and I did like the TV adaptation of The Stand.