Derby, UK: Jurors sentenced for contacting men they'd just convicted

Jurors sentenced for contacting men they’d just convicted because they ‘felt sorry for them’

Two jurors have been sentenced themselves after they contacted two men they had found guilty of drugs offences just hours before, because they felt sorry for them.

Derby Crown Court heard how George Matthews and Katherine Davies were members of a jury which convicted the two men at the same court. Having handed down the verdict, some of the jurors went drinking afterwards, where, feeling guilty about their decision, Matthews and Davies hunted for both men on social media, and made direct contact with them, which is against the law.

They disclosed their secret jury deliberations, which led to the men appealing their sentences at the Court of Appeal, costing the taxpayer thousands of pounds.

The prosecutor, Sarah Allen, said George Matthews, 30, from Allenton, and Katherine Davies, 26, from Darley Abbey, sat on the jury for the six week trial in autumn 2021.

She said; “Matthews decided to contact (one of the defendants) over Snapchat and Davies contacted (a second defendant) saying she was in the pub all afternoon and began a flirtatious conversation. Matters came to light when one of the defendants told his solicitor the following day. As a result of their actions three defendants appealed their sentences (at the Court of Appeal in London) but they were unsuccessful.”

Matthews and Davies both pleaded guilty to intentionally disclosing jury deliberations, and were handed four-month sentences, suspended for a year. They were also told to carry out 200 hours of unpaid work each.

Drunken stupidity … :man_shrugging:

1 Like

If they are that stupid,they should never have been on jury service.
That`s a worry really Omah.

1 Like

I’ve no sympathy for anyone involved in drug related crimes.
What a stupid thing to do contacting the offenders .
What is said by a jury should remain behind closed doors otherwise how can they free to say what’s on their mind .
It could lead to being victimised at a later date

2 Likes

I was under the impression all jurors were given either written or verbal advice about these issues before the case started?/