Boris Johnson's conference speech fact-checked

Boris Johnson has given his first in-person speech to the Conservative Party conference since the Covid pandemic struck.

Promising “radical and optimistic conservatism” he made claims about the economy, wages, and housing - and repeated some familiar pledges.

‘We now have the fastest growth in the G7’

The G7 is a group of big economies. UK GDP, a measure of everything produced in the country, grew 4.8% between April and June, compared with the first three months of the year, and he’s right - that is more than any other G7 country. But the UK economy was hit particularly hard by the pandemic, which means it takes more growth to get back to where we started.

If you take a longer view, the picture looks less rosy. If you compare GDP between April and June 2021 with the last three months of 2019, before the pandemic hit, the UK had the joint-fifth best growth in the G7, equal with Germany, and with only Italy doing worse.

Selective statistic

48 new hospitals, 50,000 more nurses’

It’s not clear what constitutes a “new” hospital, as the pledge Mr Johnson is talking about includes refurbishments of existing hospitals. The plan is for them to be built by 2030, so this is still a work in progress.

So far, construction has begun at six sites. One is a new cancer hospital in Bath. The other five were hospital builds planned under pre-existing schemes (over the last decade) and include building work that stopped after the collapse of the construction firm Carillion.

The Conservatives promised 50,000 more nurses for England by March 2025.

The latest figures show there were 310,251 full-time equivalent NHS nurses and health visitors in June 2021. While that is up 14,158 since December 2019, it still leaves 35,842 full-time equivalent posts to fill over the next three-and-a-half years.

Pie in the sky

‘We have done 68 free trade deals, and that great free trade deal with our friends in the EU’

He’s right that deals have been done with 68 countries plus the EU, but there’s a big caveat. Nearly all of these deals - 63 of them in fact - are “rollover” deals. That means they copied the terms of deals the UK already had when it was an EU member, rather than creating any new benefits.

Deals with Japan and with Norway, Iceland and Liechtenstein are slightly different than the EU deals they replace, and the UK has also agreed in principle a free trade deal with Australia, which the EU has not.

But by far the most important agreement - the one with the EU itself - creates additional barriers to trade which were not there when the UK was part of the EU single market, particularly for services.

And the big Brexit hope of an early free trade deal with the United States has not been fulfilled.

Massive distortion of the truth

‘In Ribble Valley… they live seven years longer than the people of Blackpool only 33 miles away’

Mr Johnson gave this example while talking about the need to “level up”.

The Office for National Statistics produces life expectancy data at a regional and local level.

Its latest figures show that that life expectancy at birth for males in Blackpool is 74. That compares with 81 in Ribble Valley - so on this measure, Mr Johnson is right.

:ballot_box_with_check:

‘We have… built more homes than at any time in the last 30 years’

The prime minister has made this claim before - we checked it in April.

The figure he has used in the past is the number of net additional dwellings in England, which was 243,770 between April 2019 and March 2020. That was a record for the last 30 years.

But that’s not just homes built - net additional dwellings is a broad definition reflecting new houses completed, plus gains or losses from conversions, changes of use and demolitions, and even some caravans and houseboats.

It should also be said that very few of the new homes are being built by the government - 82% of the completions were from private enterprise, 17% from housing associations and 1% from local authorities.

Other indicators suggest that the figures for 2020-21 will have been considerably reduced by the pandemic when they are released in November.

Distortion of the truth

‘Wages are going up faster than before the pandemic began’

In the three months to March 2020, the average salary was worth 1% more than it had been a year before.

The most recent figures, for April to July 2021, estimate that the average salary was worth 4.5% more than a year before.

Since average salaries dipped in the first few months of the pandemic, comparing this July with last July looks like a record rise - but more because of lows back then than highs right now.

Work and Pensions Secretary Therese Coffey said the figures had been “skewed and distorted” and described recent average earnings rises as a “statistical anomaly”.

And as a result, the government decided, for this year, to break their manifesto pledge to increase pensions by at least as much as wage growth.

While the most recent figures exaggerate the growth in wages, Office for National Statistics analysis that tried to strip out the distortions suggests that Mr Johnson was probably correct.

:heavy_check_mark: So, true … but:

Prices have been rising in recent months, which is likely to eat into wage increases, while many in the public sector have had their pay frozen.

No outright lies but not a lot of truth, either … :man_shrugging:

1 Like

Mark Twain, “There are three kinds of lies: **lies, damned lies, and statistics.”

1 Like

In an upbeat address peppered with jokes, but light on new policy, the prime minister claimed a high-wage, high-skilled economy was being created in the wake of Brexit and the pandemic. He also defended tax rises to pay for the NHS and vowed to fix social care.

The main theme of his speech was “levelling up”, with the PM saying that reducing gaps between regions would ease pressure on south-eastern England, while boosting places that felt left behind. He also repeated pledges set out at during his party’s conference this week in Manchester to crack down on crime, improve transport links and broadband, and reform the housing market.

And he sought to reassure Tories anxious about plans to increase National Insurance to pay for the NHS and social care by claiming it was what predecessor Margaret Thatcher would have done, if the economy had been hit by a “meteorite” like the pandemic.

“She would have wagged her finger and said that more borrowing now is just higher interest rates and even higher taxes later,” he said.

She wouldn’t have been happy about BJ’s recent borrowing then, much of which was wasted on implementing “moonshot” projects and filling cronies coffers.

Covid response pushes UK borrowing to highest since second world war

Emergency pandemic measures led to a rise from £57bn to more than £303bn in 2020-21

The level of borrowing pushed the UK’s total accumulated public debt to 97.7 per cent of GDP, the highest level since the early 1960s.

The borrowing estimate for 2020-21 will rise in the months ahead when the ONS includes estimates for the likely losses the government will suffer on its loan schemes to businesses.

Can the UK afford all this debt?

Until recently, the government has been able to borrow easily at very low interest rates, which has made its debt more affordable.

At the moment it pays just 0.77% interest to borrow for 10 years.

It’s still low but interest rates have been rising recently - and the higher they go, the harder it will be to support the UK’s debt burden.

And in any case, interest payments will weigh on future generations until the debt is paid off, meaning there is less money available for public services, or tax cuts.

1 Like

I think his speech was more interesting in what he did not say.:smiley:
But I suspect the usual suspect here will tell us that we and the media are all biased against this woefully inadequate conservative government.

2 Likes

No governing body has a lot to work with anymore, it seems, but to try to shake something up is notable.

2 Likes

The man couldn’t shake milk :frowning:

Quite so and by heck don’t things need a good shaking up too.
:grin:

1 Like

I love people who quote the BBC as fact checkers.

The hypocrisy is eye watering. With a bit of luck Nadine Dorries will defund them and then we don’t have to pay for all that shit the BBC spews out. They tried to destroy our democracy, they contributed to Princess Dianas Death and lied consistently through the general election. To quote them as fact checkers is simply laughable.

Hopefully the communist propaganda channel with its over paid morons will be a thing of the past soon.

1 Like

Up here in Scotland the BBC is so terrified of losing its dominant position if and when Scotland becomes independent that there are no programs or presenters or reporters employed by them that take the SNP Government to task except for a token appearance from Glenn Campbell a political editor on a Sunday morning.

It is quite worrying how biased BBC Scotland is.

1 Like

Business leaders and think tanks have described Boris Johnson’s party conference speech as “economically illiterate”.

The prime minister’s speech to the Conservative Party Conference on Wednesday came as many businesses are struggling with supply chain issues and a lack of workers.

A shortage of HGV drivers has resulted in a reduced supply of fuel in some parts of the country, along with warnings of empty shelves and rising costs ahead of Christmas.

But Mr Johnson defended his strategy of restricting the supply of cheap foreign labour in post-Brexit Britain, saying that the economic strain seen over recent weeks were part of the transition people voted for.

Business leaders were not impressed, with many saying that restricting migration could see inflation rise, with consumers left to bear the costs.

Matthew Lesh, head of research at free market think tank the Adam Smith Institute, said:

“Boris’s rhetoric was bombastic but vacuous and economically illiterate. This was an agenda for levelling down to a centrally-planned, high-tax, low-productivity economy. Boris is hamstringing the labour market, raising taxes on a fragile recovery and shying away from meaningful planning reform. Shortages and rising prices simply cannot be blustered away with rhetoric about migrants. It’s reprehensible and wrong to claim that migrants make us poorer. There is no evidence that immigration lowers living standards for native workers. This dogwhistle shows that this government doesn’t care about pursuing evidence-based policies. We can both control migration and allow migrants to fill skill gaps.”

Richard Walker, managing director of supermarket chain Iceland, said the government was treating businesses like an “endless sponge” but they can only weather so many cost increases at once.

He told The Times:

“The finger is being pointed at business as the bogeyman, but it’s much wider than that. We want to pay our people as much as possible but business is not an endless sponge that can keep absorbing costs in one go. Next year we’ll have a wave of higher costs from higher energy bills, extra HGV drivers, packaging costs. We can only weather many cost increases at once, so they need to taper it.”

Federation of Small Businesses national chair Mike Cherry said:

“It’s a relief to hear the PM speak positively about the business community. But it’s equally remarkable to hear the benefits of a low tax economy vaunted when the government has just signed off a hike in national insurance contributions for employers, sole traders and employees alike, which we estimate will cost at least 50,000 jobs. If this government wants a high wage, high skill, high productivity economy then it needs to stop hitting our 5.9 million small businesses with high tax bills before they’ve made a pound in turnover, let alone profit.”

Them’s harsh words, pardner … :cowboy_hat_face:

The BBC is where the truth and entertainment goes to die.

Furious business bosses have lined up to accuse Boris Johnson of leading Britain into a “cost of living catastrophe” without a credible plan to tackle the crises piling up for the economy.

Even former Tory loyalists such as Brexiteer Wetherspoon pubs boss Tim Martin joined the attack saying the Prime Minister headed a Government “lurching from one unpredictable initiative to another” with the least “commercial savvy” or “guiding philosophy” of any administration for 40 years.

The extraordinary row between a Tory leadership and captains of industry, normally seen as natural allies, was first triggered by an article in the Evening Standard on Monday, written by Leave-supporting Next chief executive Lord Wolfson.

The Tory peer called on the Government to allow businesses to hire more foreign workers to ease labour shortages that have led to chaos at filling stations, restaurants having to close and warnings of empty shelves at Christmas. The stand-off worsened yesterday when Mr Johnson dismissed the concerns in his speech to the Tory party conference in Manchester. Instead, he insisted that business could no longer “use immigration as an excuse for failure to invest in people, in skills and in the equipment the facilities the machinery they need to do their jobs.”

But Paul Drechsler, chairman of business group London First, which represents around 200 of the capital’s largest employers, hit back, telling the Standard: “This ‘blame game’ is absolute nonsense from politicians who failed to listen, never had a plan and still don’t have a plan. Burying heads in the sand at the scale of dislocation and pain that consumers and small businesses will have to bear as a result, risks turning a crisis into a cost of living catastrophe.

“The Government should flex its own points-based immigration system to enable the economy to get the skills it needs so the recovery can continue.” In a further sign of the differing views at the top of the Tory party, Andy Street, the Conservative Mayor of the West Midlands and former John Lewis boss, backed Lord Wolfson’s call for some short-term flexibility while there is long-term adjustment. “I do agree with that, that’s common sense,” he told ITV’s Peston Show.

Andrew Large, director general of the Confederation of Paper Industries, told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme that industry needed a “temporary winter cost containment measure to try to put a lid on those costs so those very, very important industries for British society are going to be able to continue to operate.”

Restaurateur Sam Harrison, who runs Sam’s Riverside in Hammersmith, criticised the: “Disingenuous optimism of our Prime Minister, who is so far removed from what is happening in the real business world.”

Disingenuous, indeed:

Hi

Boris is a known, proven liar.

He is at it again.

Why people vote for him is beyond me.

1 Like