In the past, I have never been in favour of compulsory voting -
if someone can’t be bothered to turn out to vote voluntarily, are they going to be bothered to check out all the candidates to choose who would best represent them? - or will they just tick any box at random because they feel aggrieved at being forced into doing something they don’t want to do?
Or, if they have deliberately chosen not to vote for a specific reason, such as lack of a decent candidate, should they be forced to turn up at the polling station just to put a spoiled ballot paper in the box.
I would prefer to encourage people to want to vote by having a more democratic system of proportional representation - that may encourage people to think their vote may count.
The current system in U.K. where we have a two party monopoly and “safe seats” which are often “reserved” for the “favoured” politicians within the party, does not encourage me to think my vote counts.
I still vote at every election because I feel a sense of duty but every time I vote, I know it will be a wasted vote because the same party have had a majority in this constituency for the last 100 years.
On the other side of the coin, I have spoken with people from Australia in recent months and their view of Compulsory Voting made me think of it a bit differently - the law requires you to turn up at the polling station for your ballot paper or send in your postal ballot paper.
However, they said that nobody is forced to Vote if they don’t want to - your actual vote is anonymous, so you don’t have to vote for any of the candidates and you can put anything you like on your ballot paper - the people I talked to saw their system as more democratic because it made sure that everyone, including people in minority or disadvantaged groups, got to the ballot box and had the opportunity to vote and have a say if they wanted to.
They said it wasn’t really “compulsory voting” but “compulsory access to the voting system”
I think it would be a struggle to get a similar system going in U.K. - Brits have a tendency to dig in their heels if they think they’re being “told what to do” - even people who normally vote would probably join a “no voting” protest against a compulsory system - I’m amazed the Govt has the got the legislation through for Voting ID, to be honest.
I must admit, our current system is a bit lax - I just turn up at the voting station and give my name and address and they give me my ballot paper - they don’t ask for any ID or even ask to see my voting registration card.
I daresay if I had a friend, relative or neighbour and I knew they were registered to vote but were not going to use their vote, I could just turn up at their polling station and be given their ballot paper and nobody would know I’d used their vote, in addition to my own.