Of course it gained in popularity with help from the ‘West’.
Western companies were/are constantly searching for ways to cut production costs, and with China-plc (Shen Zhen for one instance) offering efficient and speedy production of almost anything, at a lower cost that factories in the west, they opt for production in the PRC.
But people were busy Lincs. We sometimes confuse profit and the economy as the bee all and end all, but people need something to do or you will have crime, poverty and chaos, not to mention social unrest…Basically what is happening now all over Europe.
Yes, but not productive.
I’ve read a lot about the sense of community and shared purpose felt by many Russians while living in the Soviet system. And the central planning approach would always enable full employment if that was determined to be a goal. But.
The stuff they were making was really quite poor. Plus the nature of the economy was that innovation and entrepreneurship was not a thing so the Soviets were falling further and further being in any new technology.
There was unrest but Soviet life reduced unrest - pretty much everyone was in the same crappy type of flat and no car so little jealousy, heating was free so they were crappy warm flats, and the police/secret police jumped hard on anti-social or anti-Soviet behaviour. Gulags and the like. And there was a lot of crime. The lack of decent goods meant a thriving black market and with that comes crime.
But as it happens, I agree with your comment on profits & GDP being the primary measure of success and a good country. These are one dimensional measures that favour the already rich. Unfortunately western societies appear to have been conned into believing these two measures are the only important measures.
No doubt it did. China’s hybrid societal system that combines communist and capitalist elements is a huge social experiment the outcome of which is not known. The new and crucial aspect was to encourage private initiative unleashing the creativity and ingenuity of the people by introducing elements of the market economy, the exact opposite of the rigid communist planned economy. That, Bob, @OldGreyFox gave people something to do rather than to do something- that being the distinction.
The most revolutionary aspect of this was to allow people to accumulate wealth! - something unheard of and basically a no-go in standard communist textbook economics. For people only knowing the capitalist system it is often difficult to grasp that one of the most depressing aspects of living under a communist regime is the hopelessness, the lack of perspective, the awareness that from a certain point onwards there will be no personal development possible no matter what you do because you’ve gained all that was officially allowed and planned for you. From now on you may only observe what others are doing, how they lead their lives. All that will not be for you. Just think about such a life for a moment. In China that problem was identified and addressed.
I agree with much of your post above but I’m not sure this part is true or even uniaque to a communist central planning economy. Rather than plan every aspect of people’s lives the system allowed them to retrain, move roles and careers and do different things. Arguably more than in the west - see how Cubans can switch into very different jobs. And as noted earlier in many cases there was a strong sense of community purpose that mostly (outside of sweet little villages) does not exist in the UK.
Plus, is there much personal development possible if you need to hold down two jobs to make ends meet and they are working McD’s and cleaning offices? For many in the west there is just the drudge of poorly paid jobs. And the need for welfare support to cover accommodation and heating costs.
I think what we are finding across these posts is the old Soviet economy and society was very flawed but had some positive elements, and the current western economies and societies work very well for a few and less well for many.
Hi OGF my John Lenon inspiration came from Azzs point about religion. I don’t agree that religion is a bad thing deliberately created to control. It’s a basic human psychological need to have spiritual sustenance and a sense of community. It’s when people start abusing it that it loses it’s benefit.
But if you try to remove religion a certain proportion of people will fill the void with obsessive beliefs or become desolate. I’ve spent decades questioning and searching after trying to fight my Christian upbringing but I have come to the conclusion that I’m not cleverer than the collective ancient wisdom. Not that I agree with all the rules, but I understand why they are valuable and still relevant.
I think Dachs may have lived and experienced communism.
Having spoken to people who lived under it, it was full of corruption and abuse. A poor person could not suddenly acquire an education to become a doctor because you needed some form of bribe to get through the application process. Hence there was a thriving black market which why there is such a strong community. Barter was and doubtless still is common. But if you have nothing to trade you are bottom of the heap.
Chatting to a Reverend (United Reform), many years ago, I asked him if he actually believed in God.
He replied that he didn’t, but a lot did, and if he could spread a message of goodness and kindness he was doing a good job.
I’m not disagreeing with that but I am suggesting that if you are bottom of the heap in a western capitalist country you are going to stay there. Same same.
Let me elaborate then on some points by giving examples of what it was like in East Germany.
Rather than plan every aspect of people’s lives the system allowed them to retrain, move roles and careers and do different things.
Not so under communism in East Germany. In the centrally planned economy, training and the deployment of labour was also planned and the targets needed to be reached. Change was not wanted because it would undermine targets set by the state which also had a steering function as they limited jobs and places at university which were in great demand. Note the difference between communist systems in the eighties and those of today.
And as noted earlier in many cases there was a strong sense of community purpose that mostly (outside of sweet little villages) does not exist in the UK.
I’m afraid that’s a very common misnomer. As @AnnieS mentioned correctly, this strong sense of community was mainly brought about by a scarcity society and a barter economy flourishing as a result. As soon as that shortage stopped , the sense of community disappeared and each went their separate ways.
Plus, is there much personal development possible if you need to hold down two jobs to make ends meet and they are working McD’s and cleaning offices? For many in the west there is just the drudge of poorly paid jobs. And the need for welfare support to cover accommodation and heating costs.
True but at least there’s a possibility. It’s an open and a free system and not an oppressive one. The reality under communism was that you knew as a teenager what your life would be like, what to expect, what to achieve. Communism in East Germany, and to a large extent in Eastern Europe, materially had nothing to offer than a hideous and extremely dangerous plastic car delivered after a waiting time of at least ten years, and a two- or three-room flat in a block of flats only provided at the cost of unprecedented environmental pollution. Free travelling was not possible. And it was a wasteland intellectually. That was all and it was so devastating that more and more people were risking their lives trying to flee the country. The ex-Chinese-style uniformity, the lack of individualism with - basically - far too many people being equal, no matter how good they were, is undesirable.
For me there were no positive elements in former communist systems and the advocates of them are usually having tremendous problems singling them out.
East Germany was notes for its strictures, oppressive police regime and numbers of informants. Not all Soviet bloc countries were as bad, which is not to say they were all lovely. And as I’ve tried to be clear, the entire system was flawed and was doomed to failure.
A western capitalist (so called) democracy can look open and full of opportunities. But for the vast majority it is not. It is so very heavily weighted in favour of those that already have. Social mobility is essentially dead. And as the opening post highlights, it is getting worse and worse.
I think they were all the same. We have just heard more about east Germany. They all had informants and secret police. It became easier after stalin died because his were the worst years.
Unfortunately that’s what democracy as we know it today has become:
- They create the illusion of choice because it’s the greedy (those behind capitalism) that control the power each political party gets. So it’s not a true choice at all.
Get rid of capitalism and the evil demoncratic system fails too - and we’re a step closer to socialism.
Pac’s, super Pac’s having to be outlawed. Cell phones on the mover need to automatically shut off transmissions / receptions except for a sound to alert the owner of an incoming, & dead movement reception of it. Basically talking on a Phone while in any motion needs to be outlawed completely.
Around my Area Eblo’s GPS sort of sux. It’s constantly dropping and searching while going State
Highways.
Don’t worry Azz, AI will get rid of that pronto. Be careful what you wish for. Everyone knows that getting rid of capitalism would cause the entire infrastructure of societies to fold and the most vulnerable would suffer most. You may think they suffer now, but that’s nothing compared to a world of chaos.
Cell phones and the Internet have nothing to do with Capitalism. They are a group of millionaires / Billionaires shoving it down Parents and Societies throat. I know a bunch of Parents who have banned
Cell phones from Kids, and the kids start riding bikes and scooters again. 2 years ago they were all walking down the streets staring down at the Cell phone. Now they hurry home to get their bikes out.
Cell phones and Internet are making Society stupids. (ONline Games) I got sick of Mario Bros 40 years ago.
I don’t think that’s true Annie - have faith in humanity, I do ![]()
It was always going to happen. We have built ourselves a technological house of cards and as everyone knows it has to topple sooner or later.
Globalism has been the main catalyst for UK living standards moving industries where the labour is cheaper and net zero strict rules are only passively observed.
The UK cannot compete with the far east even considering the cost of transport.
So other than financial stuff, investment in world trade, and Ai reducing workers and jobs it leaves 70 million people (climbing each year by slack boder control and himmigration) with nothing to do except live off benefits and an ever rising minimum wage which stifles employment by large companies.
Remember that more wars are created over religion/faith than anything else
Erm…I think not realspeed… ![]()
Sure, there have been troubles between different religions but most wars are caused by politics or greed.