The line between Mental Health, and day to day minor crisis management, seems to have become blurred over the years.
4 Likes
Bring back national service for men and women and many so called mental heath issues will vanish
3 Likes
Because national service will solve everything…
2 Likes
This is an important issue to discuss.
It does seem that there has been a significant rise in mental health problems. The statistics show this - so many signed off from work due to depression or other issues. Personal experience seems to back this up - pretty much every family I know has one child (most often now an adult) who has suffered badly from mental health challenges. I’ve worked people who have been diagnosed as clinically depressive and they struggled with some aspects of work.
The problems I’ve been made aware of are:
Children can get support from the NHS, psychologists etc, up until they are 18 then the support stops. Obviously the mental health issues do not stop.
It is quite easy to adapt your answers to the mental health assessment questionnaire to get the right outcome, provided you do some research first, and then get benefits.
It seems easy to place some of the blame onto parents but this does not explain how one child can grow up to have issues but their sibling(s) might not
Social media does not seem to help at all, and it may such health issues worse for some children and young adults
For certain people growing up the pressure to have to get work and earn a living is greatly reduced - basically their parents can keep paying for them. Does this mean there is no driver to make someone find their own way through mental health issues and knuckle down?
As has been noted already, this is not really a new issue. But it does seem to be a growing issue. Or perhaps the expectation that help and support will be given, and the stigma has reduced, means more people are willing to get such a diagnosis?
2 Likes
Here in the U.S., reading about our completely dysfunctional government causes a lot of anxiety in people. I don’t think providing free therapy is going to help anyone. That’s like going into a torture chamber and providing counseling to the victims but allowing the torture to persist.
The source of the anxiety needs to be addressed – not just the symptoms, although a couple of drinks doesn’t hurt as long as you don’t drive or get violent when you’re drunk.
Society today is %$#@!ed. Housing is unaffordable, we have runaway inflation in every realm including the price of gas, tuition for higher education is out of reach for many young people, AI is making entire career fields obsolete, robotics are replacing jobs, and it’s only going to get worse!
So it’s no surprise that there’s a mental health crisis.
It’s actually surprising that people have been as restrained as they are. They’re exhibiting enormous self-control by not going out and trying to bring down the entire system!
2 Likes
It would seem there are benefits to be had from bad mental health.
1 Like
It’s not like an illness or injury you can see Spitty, so I’m sure that there are bogus claims, the question is…How many, and is it fuelling the recent rise in claimants?
Google quotes…
Some stuff starts in the womb probably Foxy, then events send it in any direction, who knows?
1 Like
I’m glad I was born when I was Spitty. I was born at a time when you could survive without a smartphone or access to the internet, and only important people had a car, you could walk to the local school, and everyone worked within walking or cycling distance.
And food was pure…and mostly locally produced.
1 Like
Laudable stuff Foxy, but a firm safe base is central to a life free from mental anguish, anyone who had this is not entitled to bad mental health, probobly.
1 Like
These days, people can chat with an AI assistant when they have a mental health issue for free instead of talking to a $150 an hour therapist. That’s a big benefit from the advent of AI. The drawback is, it might be taking work away from therapists.
Mental helth is a sympton of society going soft. Starting in schools where respect is not taught and discipline has gone out the window.
In my day start of the 1950/1960 it didn’t take much to be given 500 lines hand written to be handed in the next day. Or worse being sent to the headmaster and having a cane bought down with force across upturned hands 6 times almost breaking thumb or fingers. PT with an ex army physical trainer expcting 12year old to be the same as soldiers. even the headmaster was sadistic only listing to one side of any event before punishment.
If that happened today there would be outrage and demand for prison sentences
1 Like
There are so many contributing factors:
- Our food is the worst it has ever been.
- Stagnating wages means young people can’t afford houses
- General cost of living has shot up
- There are so many depressing genocides and wars
- And finally, people are waking up to the fact we are all just slaves for the ruling classes
On top of that there’s social media and every phone has a camera, so people now will never have a private moment or room to make mistakes.
I really do feel sorry for young people the most, in many ways it’s the worst time to have been born… and now with AI Surveillance centres, it’s going to get even worse.
Something I generally do is try to be a positive force in the life of others, even if that is to spend a bit of time talking to someone - because life’s hard, and if I can make someone feel a little better just by giving them a few moments of my time, maybe it could help make a difference, or if they were on the brink, make them reconsider.
But again, billionaires and the ruling classes are to blame - for pretty much everything. Our world could be so much better, but it’s not, because of greed and the vile capitalist exploitative system most of us live in.
5 Likes
The situation is incredibly nuanced isn’t it Azz? Regardless of a person’s beginnings in life, status, resolve, moral strengths etc things can happen on the journey. For want of a better word everybody has their ‘tolerances’ . I’ve known relatively strong people encounter situations which they have found or perceived to be insurmountable, sometimes the consequences were devastating!
2 Likes
Rightly so!
1 Like
We had the cane but it was not administered to the hands. 
1 Like
Don’t think social change is responsible for much of it, that’s always gone on.
I tend to agree but who provide jobs in the first place? that is the other side of the coin.
1 Like
I’m always doubtful of the claim that the young generation are in some way less robust or capable than “we were back in my day”. The 20-30’s year old today may have different values and priorities but they’re pretty much the same as all previous generations.
One thing that has changed enormously is the scope for optimism and a future to look forward to. People still want the same things as before - a decent job, with decent pay and decent prospects, housing security, the opportunity to have a family, the prospect of having a bit of spare money to indulge in stuff you like or like to do. These things people look forward to and plan for - and the confidence that such things are possible creates optimism about one’s future.
Today much of that has been removed. Its hard to get a job. Many jobs don’t pay that well (relative to costs) and are insecure - even well paid ones. The job prospects are increasingly doubtful. Housing, to buy or rent, is increasingly unaffordable. Having children appears to be unaffordable or impractical if you depend on two salaries. This means there is little to look forward to and few reasons to be optimistic.
I’m not saying that this is the only cause of mental health problems but we’ve created a society where such problems are more likely.
3 Likes
One of the main reasons why I have always wandered in the wild places Azz.
1 Like