First ever photo of a Black Hole!

When you say “an image” what that really means is that at some point a HUMAN has taken radio wave data and used his/her own interpretation of that to translate it into a visual picture.

It is therefore just a piece of art is it not? Technically the structure of the image dutifully conveys the reality of the radio sources but in terms of artistry, colours etc those are surely made up by the artist.

Jeez. :frowning:

I give up. :frowning:

So I’m thinking ‘This is marvellous!’ was it NASA or perhaps the European Space Agency who allowed us a galactic out of this world peek at space?..No! it was NDTV…from New Delhi…Sorry, Who?

NDTV
Media company
Image result for ndtv
ndtv.com
DescriptionNew Delhi Television Limited is an Indian television media company founded in 1988 by Radhika Roy, a journalist. In a talk on the 25th anniversary of NDTV, her husband Prannoy Roy said that he joined NDTV a few weeks after Radhika had founded it. Wikipedia
CEO: Suparna Singh (4 Dec 2017–)
Headquarters: New Delhi, India
Number of employees: 1,491 (2016)
Founders: Prannoy Roy, Radhika Roy
Subsidiaries: NDTV Lifestyle Limited, NDTV Worldwide Limited,

Will not affect my life one jot.

They nicked it and have since apologised for taking ownership, they steal anything that isn’t nailed down

Stole it!

 So  is  this  whole (forgive  the  pun ).  Black  hole  thing  just
 fake  news  then?

  Regards      Donkeyman!

Well actually Donkeyman it’s a hole, and holes tend to be very illusive, it’s only because of the effect it has on the things around it that we think there’s something there. It’s just like a packet of ‘Polo’s’ you only know the hole is there because it’s surrounded by mint, take away the mint and you would never know if the packet was still full of the holes…:017:

Take for example the story about ‘The King’s New clothes’ that’s the same as the story about ‘man made global warming’ we only know it’s happening because we get ‘Weather’ now…:069:

You mean?

Is that why my pockets are allways empty!
Because they are full of holes? OGF!
I allways thought black holes were super dense gravity fields,
Which pull in any unwary objects that approach too closely,
Thus becoming ever more dense, ad infinitum!
I got a grip of your anologies much better though, thank you!

Best  Regards    Donkeyman!

PS   l  do  find  this  subject  very  interesting  though!

You two are so funny! :lol: :lol: :lol:

Two funny

Do you mean funny ha ha or funny peculiar Pyxel?

  Best   Regards     Donkeyman!

Funny haha!

Although I don’t know if you’re meaning to be funny! :lol::lol:

You make me laugh, anyway! :lol:

Tongue in cheek stuff Pyxell…:wink:

But like Donkeyman I do love the subject…:cool:

A very interesting topic. Two questions I know there is no answer to. 1. Is there an edge to the universe or is it endless? 2. We are led to understand the universe started with a ‘Big Bang’ What was there before the Big Bang?
Now, how many of you believe we have visitors (UFOs) from inner or outer space? I don,t!!
PS Yes I know what you are saying. If there are no answers to the questions then why ask them.

‘Before’ has no meaning in relation to the Big Bang, time requires mass so time didn’t come into existence until the Big Bang had already started. If there is no time then ‘before’ and ‘after’ have no meaning.

I don’t understand it either.

Before and after?

 Perhaps  the  whole  thing(  corny  l  know )  is  really  just
now!  
 Nothing  before  nothing  after,  just  NOW!  Brucy?

 Regards      Donkeyman!

Anyway! That’s not the first picture of a ‘Black Hole’…:018:

Using Foxy’s faraway foto machine I managed to take this last year…:cool: The ‘Black Hole’ is top left, you have to really look for it…:surprised: It appears Grey without the filter…:wink:

Hazy Hole?

The grey sphere is the hole is it OGF?
Looks to be a very regular shape to me? but when you
thnk about it, l suppose it would be if it was formed by
gravity.
I have a question for you though, l used to look at the
southern hemisphere skies and l observed( by eye and by
binoculars ) patches of sky that were blacker and contained
no stars at all, in an otherwise star studded area of sky!
My question is, what are these barren patches of sky?
My second question is, are they what is called black
Matter?

  Best  Regards      Donkeyman!

It’s really hard to imagine that time is totally tied up with the existence of space. If there is something out there beyond space, but isn’t space, then time goes right along with it. No space? No matter either, as we understand it.

One way to think of the universe is that we are like a raisin in a loaf of bread dough. As it is heated, it expands in all directions around us. We can try to get to the edge to see what is out there because the bread is expanding faster than we can reach it (if it exists).

Ok, so we can’t find out what lies beyond the universe, but what about black holes? We won’t ever know either, because they won’t release the only thing we can currently measure - electromagnetic radiation.

Realist, back to your comment. Everything we see and measure on the electromagnetic spectrum - is an image. Even the images that our brains create are images. That doesn’t mean the objects we perceive don’t exist. The dresser that I bumped into in the dark was most certainly there, but it looks different during the day, it looks different in an infrared image, and would look altogether different if I took an x-ray image. No matter what, my toe still hurts :cry:.

This whole “Universe expanding” concept is interesting. If something is expanding then whatever its essence it, must be being stretched and gradually compromised. Such things reach a critical point where something breaks (like a rubber band snapping) or where the structural integrity is strong enough to resist breaking in which case the forces that originally caused the expansion are overcome and the expansion begins to reverse, like a bungee jumping rope.

Either way the future would seem somewhat bleak.

The other option is that the expansion is due to ever increasing amounts of matter. Bread dough initially doubles or trebles in volume because the yeast organisms are replicating at a fast rate and creating more and more ethanol and CO2 as they do so. So it is real volume increase rather than stretching. When the bread is baked it expands due to the heat acting on the CO2 and stretches but only to a point.

So what is actually happening to the universe? Is it’s very material stretching due to some ancient cataclysmic force or is it actually growing, expanding as a living organism?

Oh there was never the suggestion that black holes don’t exist. I was merely highlighting that the depictions that were posted are at the end of the day an artists impression, even if created electronically. Any colours are surely coded by humans.

There’s one school of thought that suggests that the universe, while expanding, might be folding back on itself.

In that way, it could keep expanding ‘for ever’.